This is another trio of linked questions, this time on commanders. We ask for the best, worst, and favorite. Best Commander in History Napoleon 18.54% Alexander the Great 16.59% Wellington 5.85% Hannibal 4.39% Genghis Khan 2.93% Belisarius 2.44% George Washington 1.95% Scipio Africanus 1.95% Frederick the Great 1.95% Duke of Marlborough 1.95% Rommel 1.46% Patton 1.46% Robert E. Lee 1.46% U.S. Grant 1.46% Marshal Davout 1.46% Nelson 0.98% General Sherman 0.98% von Manstein 0.98% Julius Caesar 0.98% No Answer 19.51% Other Answers 9.26% Worst Commander in History Hitler 8.29% Douglas Haig 3.90% George B. McClellan 3.90% Braxton Bragg 2.93% Napoleon 2.93% Burnside 2.44% Elphinstone 2.44% Sadaam Hussein 2.44% Darius 1.95% Varus 1.95% George Custer 1.46% Westmoreland 1.46% ["Me"] 1.46% Benedek 0.98% Charles the Bold 0.98% Douglas MacArthur 0.98% Gen. Gates (AWI) 0.98% Hooker 0.98% Mack 0.98% Patton 0.98% Varro 0.98% Xerxes 0.98% No Answer 36.59% Other Answers 17.56% Favorite Commander in History Napoleon 9.76% George Patton 7.32% Louis Nicolas Davout 3.90% U S Grant 3.90% Rommel 3.41% Robert E. Lee 3.41% Wellington 2.93% Hannibal 2.44% George Washington 2.44% William T. Sherman 1.95% Charles XII 1.46% Alexander the Great 1.46% Maurice de Saxe 1.46% Stonewall Jackson 1.46% von Manstein 1.46% Sir William Slim 1.46% Frederick the Great 0.98% Robert Guiscard 0.98% Nathaniel Greene 0.98% Julius Caesar 0.98% Joshua Chamberlin 0.98% Duke of Marlborough 0.98% No Answer 22.93% Other Answers 20.48% Other Best Commanders: 1 Vote each: Franco, Guderian, Jan Ziska, Eugene of Savoy, Maurice de Saxe, Montgomery, Murat I Sultan of Ottoman, Nathanial Greene, Moltke, Chuikov, Robert Guiscard, Robertson, Bradley, Stonewall Jackson, Tamerlane, Winfield Scott, no idea, no one, Too many eras to pick one., Other Worst Commanders: 1 Vote each: Baratieri, Benjamin Butler, Bonnie Prince Charles, Cardigan, Edward II, Enver Pasha, Franco, Gage, Gamelin, Gen. Montgomery, Gideon Pillow, Hood, Horatio Gates, James Wilkson US--War of 1812, John Burgoyne, John French, Kaiser Wilhelm II, King Darius of Persia, Lord Raglan, Lt. Kelly, Mark Clark, Mathias Gallas, Montezuma, Mussolini, My last CO, Pick a Union ACW Commander, Raglan, Santa Anna, Stalin, T.E. Lawrence, Tibor Vari, Tsar Nicolas, US Grant, Wellington, Much too competitive to pick only one Other Favorite Commanders: 1 Vote each: Sir John Moore, Scipio, Rosecrans, Sidney Smith, Saladin, Oliver Cromwell, Conner British WWII, Tewfik Bey, Urien ap Rheged, Soult, Marshall, Prince Rupert, Von Moltke, Louis Gabriel Suchet, Lord Hopton, Leonidas, Kuroki Japanese 1st Army 1904-05, Katukov, Joe Stilwell, J.E.B. Stuart, Winfield Scott Hancock, Gustav Adolphus, Wm. Stark Rosecrans, Georgi K. Zhukov, Gen. Morgan (AWI), Duc de Broglie, Nathan Bedford Forrest, Col Fred Burnaby, Claude Auchinleck, Cipriano Mera, Murat I Sultan of Ottoman, Capt. John Parker 1775, Bindon Blood, Bernhard of Saxe-Weimar, Belisarius, Barclay de Tolly, Aristonicus, Archduke Charles, Maj. Robert Merriman (Lincoln Bttn), Admiral Nelson, Thomas (ACW), No opinion MagWeb.com Analysis Quite a few commanders that are difficult to select in each category when you have to pick just one, as one respondent noted. I'm not quite sure of the lack of confidence for the folks who responded to the "Worst" commander category with "me," (as in themselves), but if they want to proclaim their level of competence as such, who am I to complain? Our VP Tibor Vari raised his eyebrows when he was named "Worst Commander," obviously more mirth than malfeasance, although he did want to know who entered it...can't tell him because all of the answers were compiled anonymously. As you might expect, in the "Favorite" category, you really get an all-star line-up, although there are some names I don't recognize. In 1999, we asked for the "Best" commander in history, ranking them 1, 2, and 3. Then, we combined the list to come up with the best: Combined Top 20 (selected regardless of preference) 1. Alexander the Great 19.8% 2. Napoleon 19.5% 3. Hannibal 5.2% 4. Duke of Marlborough 4.3% 4. Rommel 4.3% 6. Julius Caesar 3.0% 6. Frederick the Great 3.0% 6. Genghis Khan 3.0% 6. Nelson 3.0% 10. Robert E Lee 2.4% 10. Patton 2.4% 12. Wellington 2.1% 13. Gustavus Adolphus 1.8% 13. Scipio 1.8% 13. Stonewall Jackson 1.8% 13. George Washington 1.8% 17. Von Moltke 1.2% 18. Belisarius 0.9% 18. Davout 0.9% 18. U.S. Grant 0.9% 18. von Manstein 0.9% 18. Zhukov 0.9% Alexander the Great really plummetted, while Patton really exploded. It's quite the switch over the last three years...Not quite sure why Patton has gotten popular all of a sudden, but considering that most respondents mentioned WWII and Napoleonic era as their favorites, it stands to reason commanders in these periods would do well... War, Warfare, and MagWeb.com Introduction: Survey Says... Members Background Favorite Periods of Military History Connecting to MagWeb.com Demographics: Gender, Age and Computer Type Member Buying Habits (per month) MagWeb.com Specific Feedback: Service Likes and Dislikes Military History Opinions Pivotal Battles and "Time Travel" Best, Worst, and Favorite Commanders in History Current Military Situation Opinions How Do You View the World? Hot Spots: Declaration of War? Coming Religious War? Is the US at War? The Draft in the US? Torture Captured Terrorists? The Future of MagWeb.com MagWeb.com Advertising? MagWeb.com Membership Pricing? Written Comments About MagWeb.com (And Our Responses) The Question We Should Have Asked What Needs Improvement MagWeb.com's Great Aspects General Comments Thoughts About Price Increase Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 2002 by Coalition Web, Inc. This article appears in MagWeb.com (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com