Reviewed by Mark Mocarski
![]() |
The Jacobites pose a quandary to this reviewer. While animation and detail regarding sculpting is superb, the detail is somewhat misleading. NONE of the Jacobite highlanders in the ' Highlanders with muskets ' pack, have a broadsword! This flies in the face of historical facts. All first hand accounts describing the Jacobite armies throughout the 18th century Jacobite wars contradict this point. Not all carried a broadsword, but MANY did. Indeed the principle Jacobite offensive tactic was the highland charge, in which the Jacobites would advance to closing range with the enemy fire a volley on the advance, and charge to close under the cover of the ensuing smoke to finish off their opponents with the broadsword dirk and the occasional lochaber axe. How this well known and easily accessible fact escaped the ranges designers is beyond. Also only one Jacobite with musket figure type comes with a cartridge box. While it is true that in most circumstances ammunition was carried in the sporran, the small leather pouch worn at the waste, this could hold only a small amount of ammo, and following the string of Jacobite victories from Prestonpans to Falkirk, to Inverurie and Forts George and Augustus, Whole enemy camps and supply depots fell into the Jacobite's needy hands. Sadly this fact is not even remotely represented in the old Glory range. Indeed those Jacobites with guns have no swords and those in the ' Highlanders with swords' pack, have no guns! Go figure.(By the way, the Jacobite targes or shields are separate to facilitate painting.) One can only hope that the sculptors will return to the drawing board and release a separate pack that will correct this error. Other then that, the range is highly recommended. Especially appreciated is the pack of lowlanders with command. This pack is useful for Jacobite lowland units as well as Government militia units in Scotland. All have cartridge boxes and some even have canteens. More Reviews
Essex 15mm Franco-Prussians Imperialist Enterprises 25mm Demi-Brigades Early Napoleonics Guernsey Foundry 25mm Napoleonic Infantry in Campaign Dress Simtac Jacobite 15mm Napoleonic Baden Range Peter Pig 15mm Spanish Civil War Command Essex 25mm ACW Dixon 25mm Wild West Guernsey Foundry 25mm Darkest Africa TCS Western Gunfight Series Langton Miniatures 1/1200 ACW Ships Old Glory 25mm Jacobite Rebellion Riversco 1/144th scale Junkers J-1, Fokker D.VI, and Spad S.XI Imperialist Enterprises' 25mm War of Spanish Succession SHQ 20mm WWII German Mounted MG34 Team Collectaire 1/300th Scale Italian Airforce Museum Miniatures 15MM Gladiators Stone Mountain Fire & Fury Markers Renaissance Ink Bases Ragwing Warbirds WWI Rules Offensive Patrol WWI Rules U.S. Marine Corps World War II Divisions, Brigades, and Regiments (book) An Army of Professionals (AWI Scenarios) Medieval Warfare Rules Ancient Warfare Rules Blue Sky Enterprises Bases and Decals Rompan El Fuego! SCW Back to Table of Contents -- Courier #75 To Courier List of Issues To MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1998 by The Courier Publishing Company. This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |