by Scott Holder
The listed Order of Battle for the Southern Campaign needs some comments, are defensive reactions on my part as the case may be. Suprisingly enough, there are gaps in the historical record as to what units aaually participated in certain time frames. The picture is also often confusing when unit sizes fluctuated drastically and companies were detached to perform operations elsewhere. Even worse, you sometimes have duplicative regiments because some were destroyed only to be reconstituted later. A perfect example of this is the 3rd and 4th Maryland Regiments. Elements of those units were at Charleston during the 1780 siege. I have not included them because of their size, or lack of size as the case may be. Yet I list them arriving with Washington in late 1781. That's because the regiments were reformed in early 1781. I have attempted to provide the most accurate OB possible given the source material but expect some differences of opinion to arise. The OB is listed for use with my campaign game using Avalon Hill's 1776 as the strategic portion of the map. The unit sizes are slewed to my AWI rules, Pour Le Merite (see The Courier #67). Basically, a battalion consiss of 12 figures of line infantry. The American regiments have an additional 3 figures which represent the light infantry company while the British have that plus another 3 figures for the grenadier company. German regiments were slightly larger with 18 line figures and 6 grenadiers. Obviously the actual Gemman Grenadier and Fusilier regiments, while being the same size, were composed of only those types of troops. The French regiments were huge, essentially 2 battalions per regiment. The first battalion would consist of 15 figures of line infantry plus 3 chasseurs light infantry) while the second would have 15 line figures plus 3 grenadiers. The special units, like the various Legions, Loyalist unis, etc, I based their sizes on the organizational structure and not actually on what was fielded. That is an important point to make with the above unit sizes. All of them are PAPER strengths, not anything real. I use a roughly 1:30 ratio. Just by looking at the American dragoon sizes, one realizes that the Americans were lucky to field 80 dragoons on a given day much less 240. I am doing this for ease of play, nothing else. Generals listed are also for use with a variant of 1776. I think their presence, and divergent ratings allows for more command control problems plus it better simulates the personalities ofthe period. One thing that we do to reflect the politics in Philadelphia at the time is to delay Greene's and Morgan's arrivals until 6 months after Gates loses a major battle. Of course if good ole Horatio doesn't lose, Greene and Morgan never show up. Also, there is a cenain amount of "what if" in some portions of the OB. For example, Pulaksi's Legion was disbanded shortly after the Count's death in the aftermath of the aborted Seige of Augusta. The dragoons were merged into Continental mounted units, the infantry into the South Carolina Continental infantry. I choose to keep it just to make things slightly more interesting. It is also something of a play balance question since the American side is woefully inadequate qualitatively in the game and the dragoons make up for that somewhat. Also, it's hard to simulate the differences in quality among horseflesh.in the American counterparts. I simulate that by quantity of units rather than some qualitative measure. Although I list militia at the beginning, I do not thereafter. That's because the play mechanics in 1776 allow for fluctuating militia levels. Since it is really impossible to try and draw up a realistic militia OB for the period and have it make any impact on the game itself, I prefer to let the boardgame do that work for me. The morale grades listed run from A through F. A class units are the British Guards, F your run of the mill militia. Some rule sets do not make the distinction between the Guards and the British Fusiliers. That's ftne, just use the morale grades listed as a guideline of sorts if you convert from one rules set to another. The important thing is to realize the differences and relationships. The British Legion had horses that were consistently of less quality than the troops involved. You also might want to take into account the possibility of morale degradation during the time frame. A good example of this would be the 71st Highlanders which are rated 'B" in my OB. Most accounts of them at the battle of Cowpens indicates that rating would be too high. In fact, the members of the 71st at Cowpens were mostly new recruits and not seasoned veterans. When gaming Cowpens as a stand alone game, I rate the 71st as "E" class. If nothing else, this OB will give the reader an idea of the extent the British poured men and material into the Carolinas in 1780 and then Virginia in 1781. Although the Franco- American alliance trapped 7,000 British and Germans at Yorktown, and equal number of troops were still left in the Southern theater although they were mostly confined to the coastal regions of the Carolinas by the end of 1781.
More AWI Southern Campaign
Part I: Post Camden to Battle of Guilford Courthouse Part II: Post Guilford to the End OOB: American and British Forces in the Campaign Campaign Rules for American Revolutionary War Back to Table of Contents -- Courier #66 Back to Courier List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1994 by The Courier Publishing Company. This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. |