Were the Prussian Positions
at Ligny Exposed

Did Wellington Criticise
the Prussian Positions at Ligny?

Wellington and the Windmill at Bussy

Another Waterloo Myth examined by Peter Hofschroer


We will next establish Wellington's movements and what he could see from the Prussian headquarters. When Wellington rode from Quatre Bras to Brye, he is most likely to have taken the main road to Namur at then turned right up one of the side roads after les trois Burettes towards the windmill. In doing so, he would have passed three brigades and Reserve Cavalry of Pirch I's II Army Corps. These three brigades were drawn up on the reverse side of the hill between Ligny and Brye, out of sight and out of range of the French artillery. The Reserve Cavalry was even further to the rear. The regimental history of the Queen's Dragoons mentions,

'About one o'clock, the English supreme commander, the Duke of Wellington, passed the positions of the II Corps on his way to meet Blucher. The regiment was fortunate enough to see this famous warlord from close up.' [5]

The Duke would have seen the II Army Corps deployed on reverse slopes and out of range of the French artillery. He would then have ridden through Pirch II's Brigade, on the windmill height and out of effective range of the French artillery. From the windmill, looking towards St. Amand, he would have seen the Prussian batteries drawn up near the windmill in reserve. These were out of effective range of the French artillery. The Prussian grand battery was deployed south-west of the windmill. It was in effective range of some of the French artillery.

Conversely, some of the French artillery was in effective range of the Prussian grand battery, so the Prussians were at no particular disadvantage here. Six battalions of infantry were drawn up in front of the grand battery, in a hollow. They were in effective range of the French artillery, but being in dead ground and in tall crops, the effectiveness of the French artillery fire must have been reduced. On the ridge in front of this hollow, a further Prussian battery was deployed. It was at maximum effective range from the French artillery. As the French artillery was likely to be concentrating its fire on the defenders of St. Amand, it is unlikely that this Prussian battery would be at a great disadvantage here.

Three battalions of infantry were deployed in St. Amand. One wonders if Wellington was in a position to distinguish them as they were in cover. These men were in canister range of the French artillery, but were in hard cover. Looking down towards Ligny, the Duke would have seen two battalions of Henckel's Brigade, Zieten's Reserve Cavalry and six battalions of Jagow's Brigade drawn up on the slope behind Ligny. These men were within maximum effective range of the French artillery deployed in front of Ligny.

As the French artillery was positioned to concentrate its fire on the village of Ligny, the danger to these men was minimal. Any overshoot was going to be up a steep slope, which would also minimise the effect. Finally, the line of sight was restricted by the village, making effective fire on these reserves difficult. In Ligny itself, there were 4 1/2 battalions of infantry. These men were also in hard cover, which lessened the effect of the French artillery fire. in and around the village of Brye, close to the windmill, 3 1/2 battalions were deployed, partly in cover, and all out of range and out of sight of the French. These men were near enough to Wellington for the Duke to have seen them. The III Army Corps was most probably out of sight of Wellington and thus, for the purposes of this essay, we do not need to consider its positions in detail.

Both Pirch I's and Zieten's Corps were each about 30,000 men strong. Wellington thus saw the positions of about 60,000 Prussians. We have already established that while riding to Blucher's headquarters, he saw Pirch I's 30,000 men drawn up on a reverse slope, out of the range of the French artillery. Of Zieten's Corps, 7 1/2 battalions, about 5,000 men, were in canister range. A further 15 battalions, 5 cavalry regiments and the grand battery, about 14,000 men in total, were within maximum effective range of the French artillery. Thus, of the 60,000 Prussians Wellington could see, over 40,000, were either on reverse slopes, or out of range of the French artillery or both. A further 14,000 were at maximum range and all the men in close range were in cover.

More Were the Prussian Positions at Ligny Exposed


Back to Age of Napoleon 30 Table of Contents
Back to Age of Napoleon List of Issues
Back to MagWeb Master List of Magazines

© Copyright 1999 by Partizan Press.
This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web.
Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com