Casualty Rates
by Various ACW Units

General Observations

by Rudy Scott Nelson



Comments concerning the names of engagements. Sometimes battles are recorded differently by Northern and Southern records. In some cases a large battle may have a more specific location identified.

Here are some examples: Stone’s River is also known as Murfreesboro, Elkhorn is Pea Ridge, Antietam is Sharpsburg.

The highest casualty rates , their unit and the battle are listed below.

    1st Texas = 82% at Antietam
    21st Georgia = 77% at First Manassas
    26th North Carolina = 72% at Gettysburg
    6th Mississippi = 71% at Shiloh
    8th Tennessee = 68% at Stone’s River
    10th Tennessee = 68% at Chickamauga

The highest casualty rates, their unit and the battle are listed below:

    1st Minnesota = 82% at Gettysburg
    141st Penn = 76% at Gettysburg
    101st New York = 74% at First Manassas
    25th Mass = 70% at Cold Harbor
    36th Wisconsin = 69% at Bethesda Church
    20th Mass = 68% at Fredricksburg
    8th Vermont = 68% at Cedar Creek
    81st Penn = 67% at Fredricksburg
    12th Massachusetts = 67% at Antietam
    1st Maine H.A. = 67% at Petersburg
    9th Louisiana Colored = 64% at Milliken’s Bend
    5th New Hamp. = 64% at Fredricksburg

Other interesting facts that I noticed were as follows:

Gakusha Pennypacker was the youngest Union General who was 20 years and 11 months when he received a brevet commission. He was also listed as the youngest full Colonel in the Union army.

BG Stahel who won the ‘Congressional Medal of Honor’ had also won the Hungarian ‘Cross of Bravery’ during the 1848 Hungarian Revolution.

BG Charles R Lowell had 12 horses killed during battles.

At least seven Generals enlisted in the Union army as privates and later attained the rank of General. The ones that I noted were C.C. Andrews, F.C. Barlow, D.D. Bidwell, Selden Conner, John G. Mitchell, John M. Oliver and William Wells.

The average age of the 132 Major Generals was 39 and the average age of the 450 Brigadier Generals was 37.

Foreign born Generals were in the Union army with sources varying on facts. Several Generals had been officers during the 1848 Liberal Revolutions and on the losing side and had to flee to the United States. Some Generals that I noted were Turchin = Russia, Asboth = Hungary, Stohlband = Sewden, Weber = Baden, Steinwehr = Brunswick, Schoepf = Poland, Owen = Wales, Klapa = Hungary, Schurz = Prussia, Osterhaus = Prussia, Count Cesnola = Italy. Schimmelfennig = Prussian Lithuania, Willich = Prussia, Stahel = Hungary, and Meager = Ireland.

Union generals were identified only by place of birth. Not ‘State’ of Commission.

    Alabama = 4
    Connecticut= 23
    Delaware = 5
    Florida = 3
    Georgia = 2
    Illinois =9
    Indiana = 21
    Kentucky = 41
    Louisiana = 1
    Maine = 31
    Maryland/D.C. = 20
    Massachusetts= 45
    Michigan = 4
    Missouri= 3
    New Hampshire= 13
    New Jersey= 11
    New York= 113
    North Carolina= 3
    Ohio= 64
    Pennsylvania=64
    Rhode Island = 6
    South Carolina = 1
    Tennessee = 6
    Vermont = 24
    Virginia = 18
    Wisconsin = 1

    Foreign Born = 45

      Canada = 4
      France = 3
      Prussia/German = 12 Great Britain = 5
      Ireland = 12
      Poland = 2 Spain = 2
      One each for Switzerland, Russia, Sweden
      Other = 2?


Back to Time Portal Passages Summer 2004 Table of Contents
Back to Time Portal Passages List of Issues
Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List
© Copyright 2004 by Rudy Scott Nelson
This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other articles from military history and related magazines are available at http://www.magweb.com