WRG List 10B: Achaeans
by Paul Dobbins and Tom McMillen
NOTES TO LIST 10B1. Following Tom McMillen's Trojan list, the Achaean CinC, and his Phthian Ally General, are allowed 4 horse light chariots, purely by reason of adding flavor. 2. "Achilles" is an Ally General, rather than a Sub General, for the obvious reason that the Iliadic tradition emphasizes the uncertain relationship of Mycenae and her northern allies. "Achilles" had not participated in the ritualistic oath taking over the union of "Menelaus" and "Helen", implying that Phthia stood outside of any prior formal arrangements. 3."Nestor" of Pylos exhibits a level of independence from Agamemnon equaled only by "Achilles". It is presumably "Nestor's" age and wisdom that allow his seemingly effortless cooperation with "Agamemnon". One can imagine, however, that things could have been worse had "Nestor" been a less steadfast ally. On a more tangible level, the excavation of Pylos has established the wealth and strength of this Achaean site, which is consistent with the deference shown "Nestor" by "Agamemnon"in the Iliad. 4. "Nestor", as per the Iliad III.292-309 for example, was the leading advocate of close order, massed tactics. Thus, Achaean warriors in a Pylian command, if upgraded to LHI, are assumed to fight in close order and must be further upgraded to HI. Please note that the 16 to 48 warriors that may be deployed as HI are charged against the 96 figure total allowed above; they are not in addition to that allotment. 5. The "Myrmidones" play so prominant a role in the Trojan Warr tradition that our list must have them. In sharp contrast to the generalship of "Nestor" of Pylos is the "heroic" leadership of "Achilles" of Phthia. Heroic leadership (following John Keegan's Mask of Command re: Alexander the Great) relies on the personal prowess of the leader to set an example to be emulated by his companions and their subordinates. If a single term can charac terize "Achilles'" personal style, it is "impetuous", ie. "irreg ular" in WRGese/ The potency of "Achilles"'s leadership allows the "Myrmidones" an upgrade to Irregular A. Please recall, in addition, that the "Myrmidones" were the tough, battle hardened Achaean veterans who guarded the northern marches of Greater Ahhiyawa in Greece. 6. These Thracians manifest the beginnings of the long term Greek practice of hiring Thracian mercenaries. In this instance, the northern Achaeans are assumed to have relieved some of the pressure on their holdings by taking some of these people into their service. 7. Finally, the Cretan (and Aegean) Danaans are assumed to be somewhat outmoded. They are allowed intrinsic MI archers in their units. The proper proportion of archers is 1 in 2, as represented in art and in the Iliad itself. Nick Sekunda terms this the "archer-pair" in his piece on the Persians in Hackett's Warfare in the Ancient World. Sekunda would make the case that the archer-pair was an historical "constant" in ancient Aegean-Levantine warfare. More Armies of the Trojan War Back to Table of Contents -- Courier #64 To Courier List of Issues To MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1994 by The Courier Publishing Company. This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |