by Ed Wimble
Several people greeted the inclusion of the Artillery Ammunition Wagons in Lutzen with less than enthusiasm; treating their arrival as unnecessary detail added to one of the few straight forward procedures in the game; artillery resupply. In a sense I agree with them. On the other hand, I think using them to mark expended rounds of ammunition a lot less complicated than having to use markers beneath or above the batteries themselves, or creating roster sheets. And the ability they give the player, to concentrate an artillery ammunition reserve, really adds a new dimension to the game. I think the biggest problem players have with them is the way they cramp, rather than "clutter" the battlefield. There is little enough room already afforded the combat units of a brigade/division by its leader's command span than to have to take the AAWs into their calculations too. In fact, accommodating them can be a real distraction, sometimes to the detriment of the brigade's performance. In order to alleviate this "cramping" I think it necessary to take them a little less seriously with regard to their "in and out of command" status. After all, it was their job to keep up with the brigades and batteries, not the other way around (players being forced to consider where they should be positioned when, in fact, the AAWs took care of this on their own.) Therefore: Solution #1:
Solution #2:
Procedure:
2. All artillery fire is executed. 3. The AA Ws belonging to the player that pulled the chit are moved. 4. The AAWs belonging to the other side are now moved. Players must decide prior to the start of the game which of the two solutions given above they will employ. More The La Bataille Forum
La Bataille de Lutzen Some Errata La Bataille de Lutzen Artillery Ammunition Wagons La Bataille de Lutzen Frequently Asked Questions and Answers La Bataille de Lutzen Example of Play: Command System Back to Art of War Issue #30 Table of Contents Back to Art of War List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1999 by Clash of Arms Games. This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. |