Historical Analysis
By Warren Ripley
with annotations by Jim Purky
Editor: The folloling article is an excerpt from Battleground: South Carolina in the Revolution and covers a little-known battle near Charleston, SC. The battle of Stono Ferry lasted about an hour, but was far from Charleston's finest. Consequently, it has been virtually forgotten by South Carolinians who through the years have seen little reason to celebrate the June 20, 1779 British victory. Large Map of Southern Theater of Operations (115K) General Augustine Prevost [1] , after failing to capture
Charleston the preceding May 11-12 [2], had led his
red-coated warriors to James Island then across the Stono River to Johns Island.
The troops marched across the island to what was then Stow Ferry, in the vicinity of modern Church Flats, two miles or so southeast of Rantowles.
Their boats followed the Stono in its slow bend around the
northern end of John's Island. At the ferry, Prevost used his boats to
form a bridge across the river. Then, to hold the bridgehead on the
northern or mainland side, he set his men to building fortifications.
The works consisted of a circular redoubt on the east and two square
redoubts at center and on the western end. Redoubts were small,
enclosed forts from which the defenders could pour musket fire on the attacker.
Protecting the rear of the work was the river. To guard the front, the British built an abatis, a wall of felled trees, their branches pointed toward the enemy. The obstacle was designed to delay the attacker while the defenders kept him under fire from the redoubts.
Often these smal1 forts were armed with cannon, but contemporary sketches of the Stono Ferry position show artillery pieces on the ground just outside the walls of the redoubts, aimed to fire over, or through the abatis.
The entire Stono Ferry fortification stretched about 800 yards
along the river bank and was flanked on the right by virtually
impenetrable marsh and on the left by open space and then woods.
Initially, Prevost seems to have stationed a ship armed with cannon at
either end of the work as additional defense, but the vessels had been
removed by the time of the battle.
In addition to protecting the bridge of boats, the work furnished
a haven to Redcoats foraging on the mainland. Even more important,
it guarded the river retreat for the British through Wadmalaw Sound
to the North Edisto River and the sea. When General Prevost
returned to Savannah not long after the British occuppied lohn's
Island, he left his brother, Colonel J.M. Prevost [3] in command of some 1,500 men to defend the Stono Ferry post.
American Major General Benjamin Lincoln, who had returned
to Charleston after his foray into Georgia, planned to attack the work
on May 31st, but a reconnaissance showed the fortification far too
strong to risk assaulting and the plans were cancelled. During the
next two weeks, both sides accomplished little. Then on June 15,
Lincoln and Governor John Rutledge discussed new plans for an
attack. It would be made by the general's troops aided by a strong detachment from the city, which was to cross by boat to James Island to be ready to cooperate with him.
Weakened Defenses
The following day, Colonel Prevost unintentionally paved the
way for this attack by drastically weakening the Stono defenses. The
colonel left for Savannah and took with him not only a large portion
of the troops, but all the vessels which formed the bridge between
John's Island and the fortification.
Large Map of Charleston and Environs (95K)
The apparent plan was to evacuate the post and Lt. Colonel John Maitland was left with about 500 effectives to accomplish this chore, a maneuver which could prove dangerous without the boats for transportation and protection. Maitland had a single, armed flatboat capable of carrying 20 men.
With this, he spent June l7-l9 ferrying the sick and wounded, Negroes, Indians, horses and baggage to the southwestern tip of John's Island from where they could island hop down the coast
toward Savannah.
Determined to Attack
Informed that the post had been weakened by Prevost's
withdrawal, Lincoln determined to attack although his own force had
dwindled through desertions and expiration of enlistments. On the
16th, he ordered General William Moultrie to be ready to move a
detachment from the city at a moment's notice, an order that involved
collecting sufficient boats to transport the force.
Three days later, the 19th of June, Lincoln ordered Moultrie to
move these troops across the Ashley River to James Island and show
his strength to the British on adjacent John's Island if opportunity
offered. Theoretically, he would then be in position to cooperate with
Lincoln's attack or pursue the enemy on John's Island at the first
signs of retreat. However, Moultrie failed to collect sufficient boats.
Only half his men had crossed to James Island when he heard
Lincoln's guns beginning the attack on June 20 and the battle was
entirely over by the time he reached the Stono end of Wapoo Creek.
Lincoln, with about 1,400 men, had moved out of his camp a
few miles from Stono Ferry at midnight, June l9, and arrived before
the enemy works about an hour after daylight of the 20th. He knew
that the British senior unit, the 71st Regiment of Highlanders
[4], would, according to military custom, be at the post of honor on the right. Consequently, Lincoln switched his own regulars, the
Continentals, from their traditional post on the right to the left -- to
face the Highlanders [5].
The American right was composed of a brigade of North and South Carolina militia and two field pieces [6] . Behind them was a small reserve of Virginia militia [7], also with two field pieces. Both flanks were protected by light infantry and the cavalry [8] was posted a little to the right and rear of the reserve.
On the British side, about 40 Highlanders occupied the circular redoubt, and the major pan of the regiment was encamped between the circular and the central redoubts. The North and South Carolina [9] provincial troops manned the central redoubt and a German Hessian [10] regiment held the left redoubt.
Alerted Garrison
British pickets alerted the garrison about 7 am, and Maitland
sent out two companies of the Highlanders to feel out the attackers.
This was a normal reaction as small units of American light infantry
had harassed the fortification on several occaisions in the past. This
time, the Highlanders met more than they could handle. They were
badly mauled by the Continentals, but fought stubbornly, refusing to
retreat until all of their officers were dead or wounded Only 11 men
of the two companies made it back to the British lines.
Lincoln had ordered the Continentals to hold their fire and
assault with the bayonet. However, near the abatis they found marsh
and a small creek barring their way. They also received a
concentrated blast from British artillery and infantry. Despite orders,
the Continentals returned the fire. The advance bogged down in the
marsh and the battle on this end of the line degenerated into a fire fight.
Large Map: Tactical Battle (95K)
On the British left, the American militia pressed the attack and
the Hessians gave way. Seeing this, Maitland withdrew part of the
Highlanders from the right, where they were easily holding the
Continentals who were stopped by the marsh, and shifted them to the
left. They doubled-timed almost the length of the fontification and arrived in time to reinforce the Hessians who raIlied and returned to battle.
Lincoln finally succeeded in stopping the fire of the Continentals
and tried to get his men to charge. But enthusiasm of the moment had
passed and the troops refused. They simply renewed firing and the
battle continued until British reinforcements were spotted coming on
the run for the ferry. Lincoln, realizing he could not capture the work,
ordered a retreat. This caused a certain amount of confusion in the American line and Maitland immediately took advantage of it. He ordered a general advance.
Cavalry to the Rescue
Lincoln threw in the cavalry to stop this new threat. But the
British were old hands at handling a cavalry charge. They formed
two lines, closed ranks and halted. The first line dropped to one knee,
set the butts of their muskets on the ground, and presented a solid
row of bayonets to the charging horses. The second line remained
standing, then when the cavalry got close, gave it a full volley. This
stopped the charge. The front rank of infantry now rose and delivered
another volley while the rear rank reloaded. By this time, what was
left of the cavalry was in full retreat.
The Virginia militia of the American reserve was sent into action and managed to hold the British long enough for Lincoln to extricate his army in fairly good order. This ended the Battle of Stono Ferry, a clear-cut British victory and one of the toughest fought
battles on South Carolina soil during the Revolution.
The entire engagement last about 56 minutes. British casualties were 129 - 26 of them dead. American losses were a bit higher, about 165 of whom 50 were killed and the rest wounded. The British resumed their briefly interrupted withdrawal and by the night of June 24th had abandoned the Stono Ferry fortification. They moved down to the southwest corner of John's Island then, by various creeks and islands to Beaufort [11] where a strong British post was established under Colonel Maitland, who proved his reputation as a first class
fighter. Maitland's action in shifting his Highlanders under fire and later stopping the American cavalry charge stand out against relatively poor leadership on the American side.
Moultrie has taken most of the blame for the loss of the battle
much of it deserved. Certainly he was negligent in not collecting
sufficient boats to move all his 700 men at one time. Moultrie was an
extremely courageous man, but not a particularly successful officer.
He procrastinated and on more than one occaison failed to take
elementary precautions, even in defiance of orders.
Blame All Around
But to blame his failure to support Lincoln for loss of this battle
is carrying things too far. Even with sufficient boats to cross the
Stono River at Wapoo Creek, the distance across John's Island is too
great for Moultrie's force to have arrived in time to influence the
battle. Moreover, the British bridge of boats at Stono Ferry was
gone. Had Moultrie reached the ferry, he would have been stranded
across the river from the battle.
He could have fought the British reinforcements, but Lincoln's
fear of these is illusionary -- Maitland had been left with one 20-man
flat boat. Reinforcements, 20 men at a time, could scarcely have
affected the battle and if Moultrie had fought them on the John's
Island side, it would hew made no difference whatsoever to Lincoln,
who was on the mainland. If Moultrie had gone by boat, the distance
is more than 10 miles by water. He would never have arrived in time
to land in the rear of the British position.
Lincoln, on the other hand, deserves much more of the blame
than he generally has received. He had ample time, weeks in fact, to
thoroughly reconnoiter the position. Yet he ordered his Continentals
to assault a fortification completely unaware that they couldn't even
get to it across the marsh and creek. He also ordered them to go in
with the bayonet, yet the element of surprise, so necessary to such an
attack, was totally lacking. Assuming the position was approachable
in the first place, he should have had his troops in position for the
bayonet assault at first light, not still in the approach pbase an hour after daylight.
Although the battle had already been lost, Lincoln's apparent
fear of British reinforcements from John's Island would have been
eliminated by proper reconnaissance. He would have known that only
a small number could be crossed and been able to safely discount this threat.
Retreat before an alert, trained enemy is always a chancy business, particularly by relatively untrained troops such as the American militia, but Lincoln could do nothing less.
His disengagement under the circumstances was well-handled. He threw
in the cavalry, likely knowing this was a necessary sacrifice to gain
time. The few minutes they bought with their lives probably gave the
Virginia militia time to get into position to fight a rearguard action and
permit the rest of the army to withdraw with little further damage.
Without these moves, there is a good chance confusion would have
turn,ed to rout and the battle might have come down to us as the
"Massacre at Stono Ferry."
[1] General Augustine Prevost, formerly the commander of British Florida and the St. Augustine garrison, assumed command of all Crown forces in Georgia on January 15, 1779. By this time, the British controlled the principal settlements in Georgia: Augusta, Savannah and Sunbury.
More Battle of Stono Ferry
This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. |