And Now for
Something Completely Different

"Our Welly" and
"Friendship's Choice"
Battle of Salamanca
22 July 1812

by Jim O'Neal


Before reading on, I must explain that my treatment of warfare in general may seem too light-hearted to some. The subject matter is so serious that I find the only way to retain any sanity is through the use of humour. In the preamble to JOHNNY REB III, John Hill makes a, similar but far more eloquent comment in regard to the captions used in some of the illustrations to that excellent set of rules.

Back in the Stone Age when I had access to a wargames club in Manchester, England, the highlight of the month was a re-fight of a historical battle. The twist in the tale was that the participants were told only the period but not the battle. If it were a Napoleonic Peninsular battle, then the terrain would be set out for a Bussaco or a Talavera and would usually be easily recognizable as such by the salient points on the battlefield and the initial dispositions of the troops.

Since the club specialized in Napoleonic wargaming, most players would be familiar with the arrival times of reinforcements, and of course the historical outcome of the battle. Our "Generals" would then attempt to avoid the mistakes committed by their historical counterparts and proceed to accomplish even greater blunders of their own making.

After a time this palled a little and, although this idea is not by any means new, it was decided to re-fight a couple of historical battles with troops other than those that were actually engaged. Since this could not be taken too far, such as attempting to wargame Shiloh with Roman Legions or the 101st Airborne, the troops had to fit into a similar period. For want of a better definition, the "Horse and Musket" period lends itself to this type of game. There were basically the three arms, Cavalry, Artillery and the PBI, which constituted the common denominator from the time of Frederick The Great to Napoleon III. Admittedly the traditional role of cavalry diminished as the period progressed. In later years troopers were actually encouraged to abandon their beloved animals and, against all the laws of nature, fight on foot. If the Good Lord had intended cavalrymen to fight dismounted, He would not have created the horse.

Until recently, my forte has been wargaming the Napoleonic Peninsular war, but of late I have developed a deep interest in the American Civil War and have been reading extensively over the past few years. I have acquired the appropriate rules and figures to enjoy engagements at all levels from skirmish (BROTHER AGAINST BROTHER) through regimental (JOHNNY REB III) to army command (FIRE & FURY). I use the now discontinued but exquisite 40mm ACW figures from Foundry and was lucky enough to be able to purchase what were almost the last of them. Thanks Neville.

"Our Welly" and "Friendship's Choice"

Now you may wonder where "Our Welly" and "Friendship's Choice" [1] fit into the scheme of things. Drawing on both my wargaming passions, I propose to offer an American Civil War scenario based on the battle of Salamanca. The opposing commanders were The Duke of Wellington, leading about 50,000 British and Portuguese confronting Marechal Marmont controlling an almost equal number of French. This scenario lends itself beautifully to the FIRE & FURY rules.

The terrain in Spain, being mostly vertical, also translates quite well into some of the more rugged areas of the western theatre of the War Between the States. The whole idea of transferring this battle through time is, besides offering some variety, to see if the effects of the advances in weaponry and tactics after the passage of nearly 50 years affects the outcome. It should also come as a good surprise to the members of your club if you tell them beforehand that they are about to fight an actual historical battle which, for reasons that will become apparent later, we have renamed "The Battle of Twin Peaks." Inform them that the OOBs reflect the correct brigade strengths present, but the commander's names have been omitted to add some suspense. It may also be an idea to offer a small prize to the first person to guess the correct name of the battle, but before doing so, it might pay to ensure that there are no closet Napoleonic buffs lurking in your club.

A BRIEF ACCOUNT OF THE BATTLE OF SALAMANCA

On the morning of 22 July 1812, Marechal Auguste Frederic Louis Viesse de Marmont, duc de Raguse [2] was feeling pretty pleased with himself. For over a month he had out manoeuvred Wellington, who was considered to be the best British general since Marlborough [3].

The battlefield of Salamanca consists of two long parallel ranges of high ground; each punctuated by a hill. The hill on the north was called the Lesser Arapile and its counterpart on the south, being some 100 feet higher, the Greater Arapile. Of Marmont's eight infantry divisions, he intended to pin Wellington with two, keep one in reserve and use the other five to march around the Allied army and attack it in the flank and rear (see map A).

Should this have come off, Marmont would have executed a perfect example of his master's "manoeuvre sur les derrieres" and no doubt cleared the Allies from Spain. By midday the plan was well into execution but Wellington had noticed the movements and started taking countermeasures of his own (see map B).

These led to a race along the inner and outer arcs of the hills.

The French out marched the Allies gaining the Greater Arapile whilst the Allies held the Lesser Arapile, but in so doing Marmont became strung out and invited defeat in detail. His invitation was graciously accepted (see maps C & D).

Seeing that a gap of a mile had opened up between Marmont's three leading divisions, Wellington, who was having a light lunch at the time suddenly threw the remains of a half-eaten chicken leg over his shoulder and exclaimed, "By God! That will do!" He turned to his Spanish liaison officer and remarked, "Mon cher Alava, Marmont est perdu."

With that, he galloped over to Edward Pakenham [4], the leader of the Allied Third Division and said calmly, "Ned, do you see those fellows over there? Throw your division into column and drive them to the devil." Thomieres' division was the first to feel the thunderbolt.

One moment it had been marching happily along expecting to come into the rear of the Allies, when suddenly the entire Third Division appeared from the folds in the ground in line of battle less than five hundred yards from its right flank. The shock to the French troops was so great that, although they had heard that in every corporal's knapsack there was a Marshal's baton, at this particular moment they would have settled for a change of underwear.

This was the beginning of a bad afternoon for Marmont. First, he saw his plans crumble before his eyes. Then, while running to his horse in an attempt to retrieve the situation he was severely wounded by shrapnel from a deliberately aimed round: an occurrence that was extremely rare in those days. His succesor, Bonnet, was equally unfortunate. He assurned the reigns of command only to be hit by a musket ball within minutes of his promotion. The task of leading the French now fell to Clausel.

While the French command was in tatters, the divisions of Maucune and Brennier were in turn routed by the assaults of Bradford and Leith with no little help from the British cavalry lead by Le Marchant's brigade. This cavalry charge was a prominent feature of the battle, and although it cost Le Marchant his life, contributed immensely to the outcome.

Wellington now assaulted the Greater Arapile. Clausel however proved himself equal to the occasion and not only repulsed the attack, but drove the Allies back almost to the foot of the Lesser Arapile with a counter attack of his own and seriously threatened their centre.

This stroke eventually petered out against the fresh troops of Clinton's Sixth Division which up until now had been held in reserve been committed by Wellington at just the right moment. By this time, five of the original eight French divisions had been accounted for and the remainder of their army fled the field covered by a masterly rearguard action under first Ferrey and then Foy. Total Allied casualties were 5,214 whereas those of the French, although impossible to determine accurately, were in the region of 14,000. In their haste to depart, they also left behind some 20 cannon.

Writing in his journal six days later, Foy was to compare Wellington's attack to Frederick The Great's famous assault in the oblique order at Leuthen .[5] A less exalted French officer put it more succinctly when he remarked that "Wellington had accounted for forty thousand Frenchmen in forty minutes."

Footnotes

[1] "Our Welly" was one of the more polite terms of affection for the Iron Duke. Others included "Old Hooky" and "The bugger who leathers the French." Napoleon, to his later regret, always regardcd him its "that Sepoy General" because of Wellington's service in India.

"Friendship's Choice" came from it murmur which ran through the French Grognards in 1809 when Napoleon created three new Marshals of the Empire. It went:

    La France a nomme Macdonald,
    L'armie a nomme Oudinot,
    L'amitie a nomme Marmont

[2] In the 19th century the French were generous in the extreme when it came to conferring names. To preserve our forests, I have refrained from using the full version throughout.
[3] John Churchill, First Duke of Marlborough the revered ancestor of Sir Winston Churchill and no relation to the guy in the cigarette ad.
[4] This was Pakenham's finest hour. His worst zoos also his last. On 8 January 1815, he thought that he would show a newly promoted general of "colonial" militia the stuff of which veteran British troops were made. In this he succeeded admirably, leaving some 2,036 specimens littered over a small field just outside New Orleans. The newly promoted general's losses were eight killed and fifteen wounded. General Andrew "Old Hickory" Jackson went on to become the 7th President of the United States. Pakenham was saved the ignominy of having to explain his defeat as his judgement had proved not just flawed but fatal.
[5] This was praise indeed because Frederick was admired even by Napoleon. After conquering Prussia in 1806, the Emperor went to pay his respects at Frederick's tomb. He stood in silent contemplation for some minutes and then turned to his Marshals and remarked rather pointedly, "Hats off Gentlemen! If Old Fritz had been alive today, we would not be here."

More And Now for Something Completely Different


Back to The Zouave Number 52 Table of Contents
Back to The Zouave List of Issues
Back to Master Magazine List
© Copyright 2000 The American Civil War Society

This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web.
Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com