by Joe Scoleri III
Players 2 Components
Box ziplock or cardboard box SimCan says: “Special rules cover the actions of submarines, convoys, ASW aircraft, mini subs, and even ASW blimps. The weapons of Japan, America, Netherlands, France, Canada, Russia, England, Italy, and Germany are included and scenarios range from one on one sub vs. destroyer actions to combined sub, surface, and air actions against the Murmansk runs.” The Reviewers say: “Sighting is the main factor in [Torpedo!] as searches must be done in both day and night scenarios ... While the game does not exactly bog down in paperwork -only sighted units are allowed on the board and search must be executed during each turn - there are moments when it resembles blind chess ... [F]or all the problems and glitches, a fun game to play and one that is quite tense at the same time.” --Kirk Stroup in F&M 22. “Somewhere in the heart of [Torpedo!] there seems to be a workable system. But as it stands at the moment, the whole product cries out how they lovingly playtested it and proofread it, then depthcharged the results ... This Torpedo! is a dud.” --Jim Hind in The Wargamer 11 “The effort invested by the designer in creating so many scenarios is pretty much lost in the abstraction of the game system; the tactical finesse needed by both participants in a submarine battle does not readily surface in Torpedo!. [A] game of Torpedo! plays more like an episode of hide-and-go-seek than an actual World War II submarine action. ... The system is easy to learn, and play moves quite rapidly. The games are suitable for two or more players, but solitaire playability is marginal. The components are nicely done, and the rules are quite functional, although it is time to see more comprehensive addenda with some badly needed rules clarifications and additions.” --Karl E. Wiegers in the Grenadier 11 “I rate Torpedo! and Submarine as nearly equal. The latter game features greater tactical detail and realism, but the former gives ASW air its due. Torpedo! has held up well and is worth looking for.” --John Vanore in F&M 62 Collectors Notes Boone lists low, high and average prices of 2/10/6.00 at auction and 14/20/16.33 for sale. Errata
Additional Information Please see page 44 for more information relating to IJN, Kriegsmarine, Torpedo! and Schnellboote. Back to Simulacrum Vol. 3 No. 2 Table of Contents Back to Simulacrum List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 2001 by Steambubble Graphics This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |