Review by Brian Lewis
This book represents the latest offering in the Medieval Battles and Leaders series published by Pallas Armata and authored by Terry Gore. Like the other five books in the series, the emphasis is on providing information which is valuable to the wargamer who is interested in recreating the battles of this period. With this in mind, the book begins with a very brief political background to the wars between the Engtish and die Scots during this 50 year period. "is is followed by a overview of the organization and tactics employed by the two armies which were involved in this conflict. The remainder of the book (approximately two-thirds of the 72 pages) are devoted to wargaming scenarios for the six major battles between the English and Scots during this period. The scenarios provided include Stirling Bridge, Falkirk, Brander, Bannockburn, Halidon Hill and Neville's Cross. Each scenario consists of a brief description of the events leading up to the battle, a map of the battlefield, suggested army lists for WRG 7th Edition, DBA and DBM, and a description of the battle itself. The scenarios vary in size and scope, some being more suitable for a small two player battle while others would provide a very interesting and entertaining multi-player game. Perhaps the most outstanding contribution of this book is the in-depth discussion of the epic Battle of Bannockburn. Separate scenarios are furnished for each of the two days of the battle. An extensive discussion of the battle is also provided. I especially liked the description of the encounter between the Scottish King (Robert the Bruce) and an English Knight (Sir Henry de Bohun) during the early stages of the battle. During this sequence the author successfully communicates the dramatic nature of this man-to-man encounter in a style which is reminiscent of some of the better works of historical fiction. Very well done! The book concludes with a small "skirmish" scenario and a corresponding set of skirmish" rules entitled "One Day in Olde England". These rules are only a page and a half long! A cursory review suggests that they are quite playable, but I have not yet tried them out as of yet. A bibliography of research sources used is provided. This is a great idea, since other wargaincirs may wish to carry out their own research on the period and would like to know where to start. Speaking as someone who occasionally likes to do some historical research, I am appalled by the number of hobby publications which do not provide a bibliography. This is unacceptable in the academic world, and should also be unacceptable in a hobby where research can play an important role. It is good to see that the ancient wargaming period is starting to experience the emergence of published historical wargaming scenarios. Other periods of wargaming, notably Napoleonics, American Civil War and World War II, benefit greatly from the large number of readily available prepared wargaming scenarios, and I am confident that ancient and medieval gaming can do likewise. My overall impression of this publication that it is an excellent source of information for wargamers interested in this period and well worth the price of $8 U.S. Copies are available in North America from Spearpoint editor Terry Gore. Back to Saga #40 Table of Contents Back to Saga List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1993 by Terry Gore This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |