Game Rating Chart


All games are rated overall on a scale of 1 to 5. The criteria for judgement are completely up to you. Rate as many games as you wish. You may rate any game on the chart and any game not listed. See also the Not Rated List.

Note: The new threshold for the ratings chart is 10 votes.

Basic Rule: One vote per game per gamer per issue max. Ballot box stuffing is not allowed.

RatingVotesGame Name, Manufacturer
4.82362This Hallowed Ground, Gamers
4.80010Sagunto, SimTac
4.792231DAK, The Gamers
4.730482Tunisia, Gamers
4.728158Hube's Pocket, Gamers
4.726588Enemy at the Gates, Gamers
4.693293Black Wednesday, Gamers
4.682625Thunder at the Crossroads II, Gamers
4.678180GD'41, Gamers
4.650100Semper Fi, Gamers
4.630138Crusader, Gamers
4.611717Ardennes, Gamers
4.583470GD'40, Gamers
4.579318Stalingrad Pocket II, Gamers
4.574319In Their Quiet Fields II, Gamers
4.56562Seven Pines, Gamers
4.560125Gaines Mill, Gamers
4.558317Hunters from the Sky, Gamers
4.537404Guderian's Blitzkrieg, Gamers
4.53488SPQR, GMT
4.528161Champion Hill, Gamers
4.528233Marengo, Gamers
4.526331No Better Place to Die, Gamers
4.51568A Raging Storm, Gamers
4.507744Afrika, Gamers
4.50034Breakout Normandy, AH
4.493361Yom Kippur, Gamers
4.478312Matanikau, Gamers
4.477323April's Harvest, Gamers
4.464248Leros, Gamers
4.418443Embrace an Angry Wind, Gamers
4.41582Bloody Roads South, Gamers
4.40922Blood on the Snow, Avalanche
4.40727Pyrrhic Victory, GMT
4.407437Perryville, Gamers
4.405479Austerlitz, Gamers
4.36075Omaha, Gamers
4.35881Barren Victory, Gamers
4.33330War Elephant-Counsel of Rome, GMT
4.35839White Death, GDW
4.35812Friedland, GamesUSA
4.32867The Korean War, Victory
4.31822Africanus, GMT
4.31619Alexander at Tyre, Thunderhaven
4.30020Alexander, 2nd, GMT
4.30010La Bat. de Corunna, CoA
4.30040Here Come the Rebels, AH
4.29341Caesar, GMT
4.29224Korea 1995, GMT
4.291351Stalingrad Pocket, Gamers
4.28628Rommel in the Desert, Columbia
4.28025Advanced Third Reich, AH
4.26715Dresden, 1813, NES
4.25048Terrible Swift Sword, 2nd ed, TSR
4.25012La Bat. d'Wavre, CoA
4.25012Desert War, AH
4.25016Roads to Gettysburg, AH
4.23967Bloody 110th, Gamers
4.22218Korsun Pocket, PWG
4.22041History of the World, AH
4.22015For Whom the Bell Tolls, GRD
4.19646The Emperor Returns, CoA
4.19646Empires in Arms, AH
4.19462Stonewall Jackson's Way, AH
4.178455th Fleet, Victory
4.17540Devil's Den, AH
4.17229Kolin, CoA
4.16718Ancients II, 3W
4.15632Duel for Kharkov, PWG
4.15413Ironclads, Exclbr
4.14050La Bat. d'Auerstadt, CoA
4.13622Triumphant Fox, MiH
4.13238Hornet Leader, GMT
4.12025Operation Mercury, GMT
4.11362Vietnam, Victory
4.111362nd Fleet, Victory
4.10154RAF, West End
4.10189In their Quiet Fields I, Gamers
4.10020Thunderbolt/Apache Leader, GMT
4.10030Western Desert, GDW
4.10020Bobby Lee, Columbia
4.095423rd Fleet, Victory
4.08582Pacific War, Victory
4.08312A Bold Stroke, Spearhead
4.07713Red Parachutes, Avalanche
4.07427La Bat. Mont St Jean, CoA
4.07128Caesar at Alesia, AH
4.056547th Fleet, Victory
4.05636Bataille Moskova, GDW
4.05139Code of Bushido, AH
4.05040Blue Max, GDW
4.04764Red Barricades, AH
4.03330Cross of Iron, AH
4.03360Fire in the East, GDW
4.03231Merchant of Venus, AH
4.02246Scorched Earth, GDW
4.01954Panzergruppe Guderian, AH
4.00043Victory in the West, GMT
4.00021Chickamauga, West End
4.00026Battle over Britain, TSR
4.00044Lion of the North, GMT
4.000208th Army, GDW
4.00015Borodino, GamesUSA
4.00017Landships, CoA
4.00031Streets of Fire, AH
4.00012Stonewall in the Valley, AH
4.00035East Front, Columbia
4.00030Napoleon on the Danube, NES
3.97682Alexander, GMT
3.97134Trial of Strength, Panther
3.96932Circus Maximus, AH
3.968125Civil War, Victory
3.96730Kampfgruppe Peiper I, A
3.96760Wellington's Victory, TSR
3.96629Third World War, GDW
3.96327Ace of Aces, Nova
3.95824Ancients, 3W
3.95848Russian Front, AH
3.95824Ancients, Good Industries
3.95668Turning Point: Stalingrad, AH
3.95522Persian Gulf, GDW
3.95141Force Eagle's War, Gamers
3.94719Dictator, GMT
3.94719Kirovograd, 3W
3.94656Tokyo Express, Victory
3.94637West of Alamein, AH
3.94637Flat Top, AH
3.93816Great War at Sea, Avalanche
3.93647Napoleon's Last Battles, TSR
3.92914IDF, AH
3.91724Aachen, PWG
3.91736Hollow Legions, AH
3.91435Panzer Command, Victory
3.91257Squad Leader (original), AH
3.90070Wooden Ships and Iron Men, AH
3.89328Croix de Guerre, AH
3.89146La Bat. d'Ligny, CoA
3.88936Air Superiority, GDW
3.88927Ring of Fire, MiH
3.88762La Bat. d'Eylau, CoA
3.88526Southern Front, GDW
3.87524To the Wolf's Lair, PWG
3.87516Britainnia, Victory
3.87162Objective: Schmidt, Gamers
3.87023Shiloh, West End
3.85770Hells Highway, Victory
3.85714Leyte: 1944, Avalanche
3.85060Napoleon at Leipzig, CoA
3.84432The Last Hurrah, AH
3.84238Yanks, AH
3.83312Napoleon, Columbia
3.83330Gung Ho!, AH
3.83047La Bat. d'Quatre Bras, CoA
3.82434Rise of the Luftwaffe, GMT
3.83034Cobra, TSR
3.82128Arctic Front, GDW
3.80541Beyond Valor, AH
3.79434Narvik, GDW
3.79329Flashpoint: Golan, Victory
3.79329Quebec 1759, Columbia
3.79248Diplomacy, AH
3.786281809, AH
3.78579Adv Sqd Ldr, Rules Set, AH
3.784102Siege of Jerusalem, AH
3.78041Pax Britannica, Victory
3.76534St Lo, West End
3.76517Speed of Heat, CoA
3.76221Bundeswehr, GDW
3.76025Machiavelli, AH
3.75929Struggle of Nations, AH
3.75040Against the Reich, West End
3.75024Torch, GDW
3.75056Up Front, AH
3.73315Battle for Germany, DG
3.73330Paratrooper, AH
3.73315Fortress Europa, AH
3.73315Decision in France, Rhino
3.73126War for the Union, CoA
3.72711Ironclads Expansion, Exclbr
3.72711Over the Reich, CoA
3.72711Autumn of Glory, CoA
3.72711Rommel at the Meuse, 3W
3.72711Crusades II, 3W
3.72662First Blood, SDI
3.72458The Legend Begins, Rhino
3.72025Blitzkrieg in the South, 3W
3.72025Napoleon at Bay, AH
3.71414A Famous Victory, MiH
3.71273August Fury, Gamers
3.71259Raid on St. Nazaire, AH
3.70848Mississippi Fortress, CoA
3.70020Air Strike, GDW
3.695105House Divided, GDW
3.68816Typhoon, GMT
3.68832We the People, AH
3.68635Axis and Allies, MB
3.68419Boots and Saddles, GDW
3.66739Republic of Rome, AH
3.66736Tac Air, AH
3.66712Carrier War, Omega
3.66721Desert Falcons, GDW
3.66715Lee Takes Command, CoA
3.66712Guadalcanal'92, AH
3.66736La Bat. d'Albuera, CoA
3.66712Glory, GMT
3.655291812, Columbia
3.64854Anzio, AH
3.64717Aegean Strike, Victory
3.64751Across Five Aprils, Victory
3.64328Fall of France, GDW
3.64314Grant Moves South, Q-deck
3.64267Arctic Storm, GMT
3.63611Battle Hymn, Victory
3.634416th Fleet, Victory
3.62237Assault, GDW
3.61513Mustangs, AH
3.61552Imperium Romanum II, West End
3.60633Gleam of Bayonets, TSR
3.58868Civilization, AH
3.58553Peloponnesian War, Victory
3.58312Henry V, 3W
3.57919Midway '92, AH
3.57771World in Flames, ADG
3.57726Air and Armor, West End
3.57540South Mountain, West End
3.57461Dead of Winter, SDI
3.57156Ambush, Victory
3.56232Bismarck, AH
3.56216Tet, GDW
3.55020Victory in Normandy, XTR
3.53813Blood and Iron, Pacific Rim
3.53132Balkan Front, GRD
3.52917Fire Team, West End
3.51927Crescendo of Doom, AH
3.51729Gazala, PWG
3.515103Lee vs. Grant, Victory
3.51339Kingmaker, AH
3.50014Phase Line Smash, GDW
3.50028Omaha Beachhead, Victory
3.50016Pacific Theater of Operations, TSR
3.50014Rommel's War, Quarterdeck
3.48431Crete/Malta, AH
3.46252Thunder at Cassino, AH
3.45668The Longest Day, AH
3.45020Desert Steel, West End
3.44134Bloody Kasserine, GDW
3.43523Their Finest Hour, GDW
3.43523Race for Tunis, GDW
3.42914Avalanche, Avalanche
3.42466Russian Campaign, AH
3.42352B-17, AH
3.41346Rebel Sabres, TSR
3.40849Edelweiss, CoA
3.40020Frederick the Great, 3W
3.400402nd Ed WW2, TSR
3.38513Crossbows & Cannon II, 3W
3.38526Sands of War, GDW
3.36411Fatal Alliances, CWG
3.34823Hedgerow Hell, AH
3.34823Planes in Flames, ADG
3.34529NATO, Victory
3.34432Battles of Waterloo, GMT
3.33318Crisis: Sinai '73, GMT
3.33324Air Force, AH
3.33315Napoleon at Austerlitz, 3W
3.32331Carrier, Victory
3.32128Soldiers, West End
3.32025Chieftain, GDW
3.32025Gladiator, AH
3.31232La Bat. d'Talavera, CoA
3.31216West Front, Columbia
3.30010Tyranno Ex, AH
3.29627Partisan, AH
3.29031Attack Sub, AH
3.28635Modern Naval Battles, 3W
3.27333L'Armee du Nord, CoA
3.26715Leningrad, DG
3.26730Lost Victory, GMT
3.26715Viceroys, Task Force
3.26357Campaigns of RE Lee, CoA
3.26050Victory in the Pacific, AH
3.24445Harpoon, GDW
3.24233Firepower, AH
3.23113War of the Rebellion, DG
3.23126Enemy in Sight, AH
3.22722Poland '39, XTR
3.22236Shot and Shell, 3W
3.22059War and Peace, AH
3.21119Spain and Portugal, GDW
3.20010Scratch One Flattop, 3W
3.20010East Wind Rain, Task Force
3.17617Lawrence of Arabia, 3W
3.17617Julius Caesar, TSR
3.17423A Winter War, GRD
3.16959Operation Shoestring, GMT
3.16724GI Anvil of Victory, AH
3.16912Piercing the Reich, MiH
3.16912Red Christmas, Thunderhaven
3.15632Arab-Israeli Wars, AH
3.15632Flight Leader, AH
3.15413Red Sky Morning, XTR
3.14314Battles for the Ardennes, DG
3.14314Britain Stands Alone, GMT
3.13622Berlin '45, XTR
3.12540Battle of the Bulge, '91, AH
3.12241Chancellorsville, CoA
3.11118The Crusades Quad, 3W
3.10329Days of Decision, ADG
3.09432Prelude to Disaster, CoA
3.08723Captain's Ed Harpoon, GDW
3.08723First to Fight, GRD
3.08559Gulf Strike, Victory
3.08312The Last Blitzkrieg, 3W
3.08312Killer Angels, West End
3.07938Conquistador, AH
3.07114Age of Chivalry, 3W
3.06715Borodino '41, COA
3.06447Campaign to Stalingrad, Rhino
3.05618Royalists &Roundheads III, 3W
3.05020Rommel at Bay, 3W
3.04445Marching through Georgia, CoA
3.02639Silver Bayonet, GMT
3.00011Mr. Lincoln's War, 3W
3.00022France, 1944, Victory
3.00023Three Days of Gettysburg, GMT
3.00015The Near East, GDW
3.00013Empires at War, DG
3.00011Alma, 3W
3.00042Mosby's Raiders, Victory
2.984611776, AH
2.98152Panzer Blitz, AH
2.97134Black Beard, AH
2.96629Last Victory, CoA
2.95824Modern Naval Battles II, 3W
2.95645Gettysburg'88, AH
2.94117New World, AH
2.92914Blitzkrieg, AH
2.92313Rommel in North Africa, West End
2.91234Patton's Best, AH
2.90521Tank Leader, West End
2.89849Airbridge to Victory, GMT
2.88234Tobruk, AH
2.86422The Seven Days Battles, DG
2.85735Central America, Victory
2.85020Give Me Liberty, 3W
2.84613Black Prince, 3W
2.83047War at Sea, AH
2.82752MBT, AH
2.82417Hitler's War, AH
2.82362Panzer Leader, AH
2.81216Salvo II, 3W
2.81216Crossbows & Cannons, 3W
2.80030Nato, Nukes, Nazis, XTR
2.78614Airland Battle, Omega
2.78614Smithereens, XTR
2.77649Guns of August, AH
2.76517East Front Solitaire, Omega
2.75016Royalists & Roundheads II, 3W
2.73126Moscow, 1941, TSR
2.73037Panzer Armee Afrika, AH
2.72744Third Reich, AH
2.70651Afrika Korps, AH
2.70427Great Invasion, CoA
2.69213Army Group Center, 3W
2.68816Gettysburg '77, AH
2.68025Light Division, 3W
2.67928Royalists and Roundheads I, 3W
2.66718Black Gold-Texas Tea, XTR
2.65223La Grande Armee, TSR
2.64314Dawn Patrol, TSR
2.63633Wahoo, XTR
2.62516Napoleon's Later Campaigns, 3W
2.61526Mississippi Banzai, XTR
2.61136Rorke's Drift, 3W
2.60010Crimean Shield, 3W
2.59061Hitler's Last Gamble, 3W
2.58312Ironsides, 3W
2.57919King of Kings, Good Industries
2.56248The Great Patriotic War, GDW
2.55627Open Fire, Victory
2.54511Shattered States, EMS
2.54224Ranger, Omega
2.52223The Urals, GRD
2.51631Rise and Fall, EMS
2.50010Cavaliers and Roundheads, 3W
2.50014Blood and Iron I, 3W
2.50010Desert Victory, Omega
2.47823Modern Naval Battles III, 3W
2.47823Grand Army of the Republic, Task Force
2.47117Chancellorsville, AH
2.44418Operation Zitadelle, 3W
2.43941Team Yankee, GDW
2.43367Guns of Cedar Creek, SDI
2.42326Four Battles Ancient World, DG
2.41217Napoleon's First Battles, DG
2.40010Main Battle Front, Omega
2.38731Luftwaffe, AH
2.36025Battlefield Europe, GDW
2.33318Normandy Campaign, GDW
2.33330Richtofen's War, AH
2.32025Test of Arms, GDW
2.30030Tomorrow the World, 3W
2.30010Platoon, AH
2.27322Raid on Richmond, 3W
2.25016Second Front, GRD
2.22722D-Day,'92, AH
2.200451863, GMT
2.19021Pas De Calais, Vanguard
2.18244Bull Run, AH
2.15233Waterloo, AH
2.11127Stand and Die, GDW
2.07114Salvo I, 3W
2.06216Shell Shock, Victory
2.00032SS Amerika, 3W
2.00013War for the Motherland, FGA
1.91712Tide of Fortune, 3W
1.900301944, 3W
1.81021Battle Cry!, 3W
1.738651862, SDI
1.72347Operation Crusader, FGA
1.55020Kasserine, FGA
1.54753Storm over Arnhem, AH
1.52917Defiant Holland, FGA
1.30333Brother against Brother, FGA
1.26730Pacific War Classics, FGA
1.23534Civil War Classics, FGA
1.22227Eagle and the Sun, FGA
1.18816WW2, 3W
1.00015Strategy, 3W

Not Rated

No Pasaran!, Alea
Asia Aflame, ADG
Assassin, AH
Banzai, AH
Caesar's Legions, AH
Dauntless, AH
Geronimo, AH
Guerrilla, AH
Hannibal, AH
Kampfgruppe Peiper II, AH
Knights of the Air, AH
London's Burning, AH
Maharaja, AH
Main Battle Tank, AH
Naval War, AH
Road Kill, AH
Samurai, AH
Spices of the World, AH
Stonewall's Last Battle, AH
Trireme, AH
Europa Universalis, Azure Wish
French Revolution, Azure Wish
Rossyia 1917, Azure Wish
Gela Beachhead, Centurion
Achtung-Spitfire!, CoA
Army of the Heartland, CoA
The Clash of Armor, CoA
Command at Sea, CoA
Close Action, CoA
Jena, CoA
The King's War, CoA
No Sailor but a Fool, CoA
The Rising Sun, CoA
The Six Days of Glory, CoA
Summer Storm, CoA
Supermarina I, CoA
Dixie: Bull Run, Columbia
Dixie: Shiloh
EuroFront, Columbia
MedFront, Columbia
VolgaFront, Columbia
Waterloo, new ed, Columbia
The Alamo, DG/SPI
Emperor's First Battles, DG
The '45, DG
Korea: The Forgotten War, DG
Krieg!, DG
Lords of Sierra Madre, DG
Napoleon's Last Battles, DG version
Rebels & Redcoats II, DG
Thirty Years War Quad, DG/SPI
Crisis Columbia, EMS
Caen, Exclbr
Cassino, Exclbr
Panzer, Exclbr
Wings, Exclbr
Bastogne, FGA
Remagen, FGA
Blood & Thunder, GDW
Operation Market-Garden, GDW
Suez '73, GDW
The Battle for North Africa, GMT
Diadochi
GMT
8th Air Force, GMT
Invasion: Norway, GMT
Invasion: Sicily, GMT
Samurai, GMT
Rebel Yell!, GPG
March to Victory, GRD
War of the Resistance, GRD
Jubilee-Dieppe, 1942, Interphase
Clash of Titans, MiH
Eastwall, MiH
Fields of Glory, MiH
Tank Commander: The East Front Edn, MiH
Triumphant Return, MiH
Turning the Tables, HiH
Lost Worlds, Nova
War to the Death, Omega
Napoleon's Leipzig Campaign, Omega
Kestenga, Pacific Rim
Taman '42, Pacific Rim
To Make Georgia Howl, Pacific Rim
Troina '43, Pacific Rim
Insecta, Sierra Madre
Trilobite, Sierra Madre
IJN, SimCan
Alexandria, Simtac
Los Arapiles, Simtac
Rivoli, 1797, Simtac
Rommel at the Meuse, Simulations Workshop
Operation Dragon Rouge, Simulations Workshop
Legend of the Lost Dutchman, Simulations Workshop
Panzers at the Pyramids, Simulations Workshop
Civil War, Smithsonian
Bloodiest Day, Spearhead
Bodyguard: Overlord, Spearhead
Bastogne or Bust, Terran
Age of Exploration, TimJim
By Force of Arms, Triumph
Barbarossa, TSR
Cemetery Hill, TSR
Morsecode . . . -, UGG
VI Against Rome, 3W
The American Aces, 3W
Barbarians, 3W
Campaign for Guadalcanal, 3W
Campaigns of the Civil War, 3W
Run Silent, Run Deep, 3W
Sink the Bismarck, 3W
Spitfire, 3W
To the Far Shore, 3W
Star Force Terra I, 3W
Spires of the Kremlin, 3W
Sword & Shield, 3W
The Civil War, Xeno
Longstreet's Assault, Xeno
This Hallowed Ground, Xeno
World at War, Xeno
Back to Iraq, XTR
Fateful Lightning, XTR
Great War in Europe, XTR
Seven Seas to Victory, XTR


Back to Table of Contents -- Operations #31
Back to Operations List of Issues
Back to MagWeb Master List of Magazines
© Copyright 1998 by The Gamers.
This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web.
Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com