'It is wonderful to see these two accounts available to readers once again. I had not read them for more than 15 years and eagerly devoured them afresh in this new publication. Captain Parker's account provides a fascinating insight into Marlborough's campaigns ... Merode-Westerloo, on the other hand, is a wonderful mix of arrogant aristocracy and professional soldier ... his critical summary of why the French lost is very perceptive ... one cannot fail to enjoy this wonderful account of this extraordinary man ... a must for the Marlburian enthusiast. They also provide an absorbing read for anyone who enjoys a good military memoir. David Chandler is perhaps the leading authority today on Marlborough. His editorship of this work is itself a testimony to its importance. Military Memoirs of Marlborough's Campaigns, 17021712 ... represents excellent value for money, two memoirs for the price of one, at £ 20. I can give this excellent reprint the very highest recommndation.' Military Modelling reviewing Military Memoirs of Marlborough's Campaigns, 17021712 edited by David Chandler.
'I found the book to be very impressive, well written, with theories backed up with compelling evidence (one can see how Peter got his degree). Whether you agree with some of his points, or even if you are not particularly interested in the German States, it should be in your Waterloo library. I'm looking forward to Peter's second volume.' Richard Partridge in Age of Napoleon reviewing 1815: The Waterloo Campaign by Peter Hofschrφer.
'Hofschrφer has written a provocative, interesting book which should serve as the catalyst for serious discussion of the early stages of the Waterloo campaign and the Prussian role in Napoleon's defeat.' Professor J. A. Meyer in the Journal of Military History (USA) reviewing 1815: The Waterloo Campaign by Peter Hofschrφer.
'Invaluable is the obvious word which springs to mind in reviewing this very welcome addition to Sir Charles Oman's magisterial history of the Peninsualr War ... Dr Hall deserves our warmest thanks ... this book is an extremely important publication ... admirable ... a very meaty tool for all manner of further research into the Peninsular Army.' Stuart Reid in Age of Napoleon reviewing The Biographical Dictionary of British Officers Killed and Wounded, 18081814 (A History of the Peninsular War Volume VIII) by John A. Hall.
'Anyone with an interest in Wellington as a military commander should do their utmost to beg, borrow or steal this book.' The British Army Review reviewing On Wellington: The Duke and his Art of War by Jac Weller.
'A really excellent collection of eleven essays writen by the late Jac Weller, one of the foremost authorities and authors on Wellington ... sound and shrewd ... a valuable analysis of his methods ... this is a valuable and highly readable book that will certainly be enjoyed by anyone interested in the subject.' Sir Julian Paget in The Guards Magazine reviewing On Wellington: The Duke and his Art of War by Jac Weller.
'I can recommend this book to any student of the Napoleonic period ... it is eminently readable ... important in the historiography of Waterloo for its original impartiality.' John S. Sly in the Army Historical Research Journal reviewing Waterloo Lectures by Charles C. Chesney.
'One of the most important reference books to be published for years, and is an absolutely vital purchase for anybody interested in the Peninsular War ... John Hall deserves immense credit, first for embarking on what was obviously going to be a long and painstaking task, and second, for finishing the job and producing such a fine book ... The book will prove invaluable particularly to geneaologists and medal collectors, whilst military historians are advised to find a place for the book on their shelves. Highly recommended.' Ian Fletcher in Military Illustrated reviewing The Biographical Dictionary of British Officers Killed and Wounded, 18081814 (A History of the Peninsular War, Volume VIII) by John A. Hall.
'Here is the ideal new year present for you. I must admit that when I first opened this book I was concerned that there were going to be too many pistol articles, which would be inappropriate to the British reader, since we are deemed unsuitable to have them. However on inspection I am pleased to say that the bulk of this excellent publication is of use to us here in the UK ... the articles are backed up with an all-embracing illustrated list of current pistols, rifles, shotguns, black powder weapons, sights, books, etc., as well as an arms trade directory. This list should give you a good idea as to how you can spend your compensation. At a time of changing shooting disciplines, this book will provide you with an excellent overview of current guns, and accessories, as well as giving you a good read.' Gun Mart reviewing Gun Digest 1999 (DBI/Krause).
'Superbly illustrated ... highly informative and extended captions ... this is good value for money.' Bob Marrion in Military Modelling reviewing Fix Bayonets! in the G.I. Series.
'If you want information on the current U.S. Army life and equipment, then this is the book for you.' Gun Mart reviewing The U.S. Army Today by Christopher J. Anderson in the G.I. Series.
'Without doubt, an aviation classic ... you get an insight into his patriotism and discipline ... an engrossing book and an excellent read.' Military Modelcraft International reviewing I Flew for the Fuhrer by Heinz Knoke. 'The Napoleonic completist will be drooling over Digby Smith's The Greenhill Napoleonic Wars Data Book ... this book represents a genuinely amazing achievement ... for those seeking basic if essential historical information there is no better source.' Simon Trew in The Wish Stream: The Journal of the War Studies Department, Royal Military Academy Sandhurst, reviewing The Greenhill Napoleonic Wars Data Book by Digby Smith.
'This massively detailed reference work provides comprehensive coverage of every action ... the degree of detail is considerable!' John S. White in The Waterloo Journal reviewing The Greenhill Napoleonic Wars Data Book by Digby Smith.
'Generally regarded as being one of the best memoirs of the Napoleonic period.' John S. White in The Waterloo Journal reviewing The Note-Books of Captain Coignet: Soldier of the Empire, 17991816 by Captain Jean-Roch Coignet.
'A remarkable volume ... for specific operations the information is convincing and of unparalleled detail ... the value of this book is immense.' Simon Trew in The Wish Stream: The Journal of the War Studies Department, Royal Military Academy Sandhurst, reviewing Soviet Casualties and Combat Losses in the Twentieth Century edited by Colonel-General G. F. Krivosheev. 'Authoritative ... the author establishes the facts behind the Vikings' rise to prominence and cuts through the myths that have built up ... an enlightening study covering three centuries of military adventure ... If you missed the hard back version of this fascinating book, rectify that now by picking up this latest 224 page paper back edition. Practical Wargamer reviewing The Viking Art of War by Paddy Griffith.
'This is an excellent book ... should be added to every Napoleonic book shelf.' Practical Wargamer reviewing Wellington At Waterloo by Jac Weller.
'Has long been a must for all students of the period.' John S. White in The Waterloo Journal reviewing Wellington at Waterloo by Jac Weller.
'An excellent survey of the Duke's art of war ... will add to Weller's already considerable stature.' John S. White in The Waterloo Journal reviewing On Wellington: The Duke and his Art of War by Jac Weller.
'An excellent survey of the Duke's military achievements.' Practical Wargamer reviewing On Wellington: The Duke and his Art of War by Jac Weller.
'Hausmann's campaign diaries are a unique primary source which describes in detail the daily life and duties of an officer during the wars ... offers a remarkable soldier's eye view of military life.' John S. White in The Waterloo Journal reviewing A Soldier for Napoleon: The Campaigns of Lieutenant Franz Joseph Hausmann translated by Cynthia Joy Hausmann.
'Previously unavailable accounts ... compulsive reading for colonial buffs.' Practical Wargamer reviewing Omdurman 1898: The Eyewitnesses Speak edited by Frederic Sharf and Peter Harrington.
'One of the most readable inside looks at the Napoleonic empire to appear in recent years. It is so entertaining that it can be completed in a single sitting ... to follow Napoleon in his study or command tent, read this book.' Blaine Taylor in Military History (USA) reviewing Napoleon: How He Did It the Memoirs of Baron Fain (Proctor Jones Publishing).
'A thoroughly well researched book and of considerable interest to the serious historian.' Sir Julian Paget in The Guards Magazine reviewing A History of the Peninsular War, Volume VIII by John Hall.
'An invaluable reference.' Andrew Uffindell in Military History (USA) reviewing A History of the Peninsular War, Volume VIII by John Hall.
'He vividly describes the spectacle of war with large masses arrayed for battle and charging Confederates screaming the Rebel yell. And he certainly gets across the excitement of battle as well as the horrible scene of the field the next day. This is what it was like.' Professor Edward M. Coffman reviewing Inside the Army of the Potomac edited by J. Gregory Ackon (Stackpole Books) for members of the History Book Club (USA).
'Even surpassing Quantrill in pure savagery ... his name became synonymous with terror and brutality on the western border.' William C. Davis reviewing Bloody Bill Anderson by Albert Castel and Thomas Goodrich (Stackpole Books) for members of the History Book Club (USA).
'Do not let the attractive format deceive you as this is a serious book which covers a complex topic without the simplifications of most illustrated volumes of this calibre ... Greece & Rome at War ... will be a rewarding read for the serious student of warfare.' Sean McKnight in The Wish Stream: The Journal of the War Studies Department, Royal Military Academy Sandhurst reviewing Greece and Rome at War by Peter Connolly.
'This is an important book about a significant war, and Greenhill is to be praised for bringing out this new edition ... Chaim Herzog's account of the war is still the best available analysis in English ... Herzog's ... personal knowledge of the key actors and events adds an invaluable extra dimension to the book ... military professionals will find that Herzog's book enhances their understanding of high-intensity conflict.' Sean McKnight in The Wish Stream: The Journal of the War Studies Department, Royal Military Academy Sandhurst reviewing The War of Atonement by Chaim Herzog.
'A splendid addition to the Marlburian bookshelf.' Practical Wargamer reviewing Military Memoirs of Marlborough's Campaigns, 17021712 edited by David Chandler.
Back to Greenhill Military Book News No. 89 Table of Contents
Back to Greenhill Military Book News List of Issues
Back to Master Magazine List
© Copyright 1999 by Greenhill Books
This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web.
Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com