by Rich Velay
The Gibraltar garrison on September 3 1939 consisted of:
Reinforcements by September 1940:
(The Gibraltar Defense Force served with the coastal artillery, AA forces, engineers, signals, medical, and admin. units. Total strength approx. 400.) Given these artillery assets, does Gibraltar deserve a CD level for the "Operation Felix" and "Invasion of Spain" scenarios in FWtBT? The scenario OB does not assign any intrinsic CD rating to the improved fortress-port, unlike other ports/fortresses in the WWII scenarios. When I play the WW II scenarios in FWtBT, I give Gibraltar 6 levels of CD, 2 for the Major Port and 4 for the Improved Fortress. One could argue for a point either way, but 6 levels of CD: (1) ensures that Gibraltar will always be able to fire some CD regardless of the hits it has taken that player turn, and (2) gives Gibraltar 3 strength points of artillery, for combat purposes, helping out some if the TFs are chased away before the big reinforcements arrive. Since this value is comparable to Wilhelmshaven and Helgoland, other important naval fortresses of the day, I don't think it overstates the CD at Gibraltar. (Note that this is based on Axis Mediterranean CD values, and if you consider Gibraltar to be an Atlantic port, bump it to a seven. If you have reason to believe it was one of the best defended naval fortresses in the world, deserving special attention, bump it to eight.) Six, 7 or 8, it doesn't matter very much since the only use for CD in the WW II scenarios is if you are using the optional CD as artillery rule, but a few extra defense factors never hurt. Once there is a game wherein naval matters at that end of the Med enter into play, I'm sure the usual suspects will fill in all the gaps.
Back to Europa Number 62 Table of Contents Back to Europa List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1998 by GR/D This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |