by Don Lowry
![]() |
To prove, I guess, that Avalon Hill is not the only game company that has problems, TSR sat on an order we sent them in February. The games arrived in May! To be fair, it was not all their fault. First we were a little slow in paying some old bills and then there was the trucking strike. Anyway, if it seemed to take a while to get TSR stuff from us this spring now you know why. (And now you know why you don't want to get into the mail-order business!) Proceding to more positive subjects: somewhere in this issue you will find the announcement of the Annual Campaign Subscribers' Awards. The Best Game of the Year (BGOTY) voting was a bit closer than last year, but still not very close. Cross of Iron received about 50% more votes than runner-up 'Crete. This was the first year there were no ties in the first five places for BGOTY. It was also interesting that a first effort, by a very small company, on a most unconventional subject - Source of the Nile - should do so well in the voting. In the Best Game of All Time (BGOAT) voting Third Reich nose-dived from two straight years in first place (after being BGOTY in 1975) into a tie for fourth. Russian Campaign moved up from a tied for second (with DNO) to first place. Apparently it is standing the test of time. Meanwhile, Drang Nach Osten, which won both categories in 1974, BGOAT in 1975 and placed second in 1976, dropped from that second place tie with RC into the fourth place tied with TR. Panzerblitz, after dropping out of the running last year, makes a strong come back to take third place. Squad Leader, last year's BGOTY, finished a strong second for BGOAT this year. All in all, 30 games received votes for BGOTY and only 27 for BGOAT, compared to 40 and 45 last year. An unusual feature is that none of the first five finishers for BFOTY received even a single vote for BGOAT! In fact, only Machiavelli and To the Green Fields Beyond received votes in both categories. Perhaps, for some reason, you thought that this year's games weren't eligible. Or maybe you just didn't think that this year's crop of games were all that great compared to years gone by. Finally, congratulations are, once again, due to Avalon Hill for taking first, second, third and half of fourth places in the BFPTY voting and first first and second in the BGOAT. And now for the "Return Fire" results from issue #90:
LOC that issue included my report of the ORCCON convention. Note that 'Prism finally cleared 5.00. For once, when you drop out the columns and things that weren't eligible for the voting, the best three agrees with the 1-10 ratings:
Back to Campaign #92 Table of Contents Back to Campaign List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1979 by Donald S. Lowry This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |