review by Bob Cordery
I have been interested in the Spanish Civil War for many years, and I am always on the look out for any new films, videos, books, articles and wargame rules that deal with the period. Unfortunately I am often disappointed because the research that has been done is often poor, politically biased or - as in the case of Ken Loach's 'Land and Freedom' - naive. The one thing I was sure of before I took part in this game was that Wayne's research would as always be excellent, and that his game would have the 'feel' of the period. I was not disappointed! These rules have a similar structure to and use some of the game mechanisms from Wayne's rules for the early part of WW1. They do however differ in certain important aspects. Because these rules are aimed at recreating the events of the early months of the civil war, there is an emphasis on the problems faced by brigade level commanders when dealing with large numbers of often poorly trained - or even untrained troops. I liked the air rules, which reflect the preoccupation that pilots had with fighting each other and failing to support the troops on the ground (forget all you read about the Condor Legion operating 'cab rank' ground attack tactics - it did not happen until the very end of the war!) The test of any set of rules is whether or not the tactics used at the time will work. In this game, as commander of an ad hoc Nationalist column, I had the job of capturing a village on the road to Madrid. Speed was of the essence and I had used the tactics favoured at the time:
In my opinion, and despite several 'cock - ups' by both sides, these tactics were effective. The game flowed along at a steady pace and to a conclusion in 2 hours. The rules worked extremely well. All in all, this was an excellent session and I have no reservation in recommending these rules to anyone contemplating taking up the period. Related Back to Abanderado Vol. 2 No. 4 Table of Contents Back to Abanderado List of Issues Back to MagWeb Master Magazine List © Copyright 1997 by Rolfe Hedges This article appears in MagWeb (Magazine Web) on the Internet World Wide Web. Other military history articles and gaming articles are available at http://www.magweb.com |